Skip to main content

More varied resources required for travel

Current situation

Currently and to my knowledge, all that is required to take into account while traveling is:

  • gold;

  • quest timers;

  • dangers on the road.

'Issue' 1 - traveling could be more spicy

The latter two elements rarely come into play in deciding where you are going to go, how fast, etc. That means that traveling does not require much consideration at all. As a result, most of the time, travel is just filling time in between quests and contracts to take, with no real purpose.

It essentially doesn't matter whether days pass, how long you take to do something, and the overworld map around you (and its implied locales, nature, ecosystems) do not provide any feedback to change that.

'Issue' 2 - resource management can be expanded

In addition, I see the game as essentially a combination of tactical turn-based strategy, role-playing and resource management. That last point is strongly emphasized by the existence of a marketplace, loot to sell and buy, and a world economy that allows for profit and loss based on player decisions.

However, most of the game's resource management puzzle-solving is relegated to dungeons (how many potions and bandages to take along, what decisions to take, when to scout, when to camp, when to heal, etc.). The overworld, while brimming with opportunity, does not yet offer the same type of challenges. It does not allow for the player to play economically, or to risk it all in an effort to sell high. It does not ask of the player to be efficient with regards to effort, inventory, space and time.

A possible solution - adding food

I believe it would be nice to have travel involve slightly more brainpower and trade-offs.

One way to do this, assuming that inventory space is/will be limited, is to add food to the game. It would be an extra resource for you to buy at an inn or marketplace, necessary to keep your party fed during travels. This is just one idea out of many, mind you, in an attempt to add more resources to take into account while traveling, while at the same time expanding existing systems and giving players more mechanics to manipulate for fun.

If food was added as a resource to take into account, it would require players to make tactical trade-offs between how much of what item they would want to take along. It would also require thinking about how much space would be left for loot.

Rather than merely buying it, one could perhaps find it on the overworld, loot it, steal it from enemies, etc. It would make traveling more complex by giving the player more than one resource to keep track of during travel.

But that complexity can also be turned into a reward: an economically keen player can derive a great deal of enjoyment from running a tight ship, keeping their crew fed and happy, while maximizing profits from travels. This emphasizes that there are more things to do in the game than merely chase combat, that there is more depth to the game than dungeon-crawling. Mind you, not that those are bad things!

2 comments

Log in to comment and vote

Comments2

  • Evin

    •

    May 10, 2022

    To be honest, I do kinda like that there isn't much to worry about for overland travel. There are other games in the genre that include things like food and morale boosting items and so on when camping on the road and while that's fun sometimes I like that this game doesn't do it, just as a change of pace. The supply management in the dungeon gameplay I think is interesting and unique enough in the genre to sort of fill that niche and is a more interesting place to invest in game design. But that's as someone who has a couple of these games on the go. I think it sets it apart nicely.

  • SunSlayer

    •

    May 5, 2022

    Regarding the food suggestion:

    I'm personally not a fan of extra mandatory resource management. However, I would like to take this idea together with an other idea I had read about food having a certain amount of time before it starts to spoil.

    I would not make food mandatory. I would, however, suggest making it an extra optional resource to cut down on the daily upkeep cost of the company. The idea is that you provide your company food by yourself and you wouldn't have to spend any gold automatically on the standard price of food. This saves money by finding/looting/purchasing food while not being a mandatory drag to constantly keep track of.

    Since food is also a trading commodity, it could be a nice idea to add an option that disallows the company to eat any food they are transporting, using the normal upkeep costs again instead.

    Eventually perhaps, there can be different kinds of food and allowing your mercenaries to eat multiple types of food from your inventory could grant them increasing bonuses. (more base morale, less morale loss, higher trust gain, ...) That could also motivate players to keep their eyes open on their resources without making it mandatory and punishing.